AI Girlfriend Scout logoAI Girlfriend Scout
CriteriaFantasyGFHeraHaven AI
Character Diversity
4.2/5(Very Good)
Great character diversity with limited search options.
3.4/5(Good)
A good selection of characters, but no options to search and filter through them.
Customization
4.2/5(Very Good)
Impressive customization experience with a wide range of options.
3.7/5(Good)
More detailed physical customizations would improve the experience.
Chat Experience
4.2/5(Very Good)
Engaging and emotionally deep interactions, but loses authenticity due to overly long, repetitive responses.
4.2/5(Very Good)
Occasional memory lapses and conversational inconsistencies.
NSFW Chat Experience
3.7/5(Good)
Playful and flirtatious interactions, but they feel somewhat artificial and inconsistent.
4.1/5(Very Good)
Engaging NSFW chat experience with occasional memory and contextual inconsistencies.
Image Generation
4.2/5(Very Good)
High-quality, consistent, and realistic images with minor technical imperfections
3.2/5(Good)
HeraHaven's image generation delivers high-quality visuals with technical inconsistencies.
Video Generation
4.2/5(Very Good)
Impressive video quality, but it costs a lot of tokens.
1/5(Poor)
Completely lacks video generation.
Voice Generation
3.2/5(Good)
The voices lack natural flow, emotions, and tonality.
3.2/5(Good)
The voice lacks authenticity, sounds robotic, and fails to capture the nuanced personality and cultural essence of the character.
Privacy
3.2/5(Good)
Unclear chat encryption and non-transparent data sharing practices.
4.2/5(Very Good)
Transparent data collection and discrete billing, but lacks explicit confirmation of end-to-end encryption in their policy.
Pricing
Free plan available. Paid plan starts at $12.99/monthFree plan available. Paid plan starts at $19.95/month
Final Score

3.9 out of 5

3.4 out of 5

FantasyGF vs HeraHaven AI

I've spent a full week with both FantasyGF and HeraHaven AI to see which one truly deserves your attention and subscription. Both platforms make big promises, but they take surprisingly different approaches.

After hundreds of messages exchanged with each AI girl, I've put together clear differences in both platforms.

In this head-to-head comparison, I'll break down exactly how these AI girlfriends stack up across all the features that actually matter.

Whether you're looking for emotional support, entertaining conversation, or a judgment-free space to be yourself, this in-depth comparison will help you choose the right AI girlfriend for your specific needs.

FantasyGF

AI girlfriend platform offering customizable partners with chat, image generation, and personalized video features.

FantasyGF interface
FantasyGF interface

HeraHaven AI

A virtual companion creation platform that provides AI-powered personalized interactions, multimedia sharing, and learning capabilities.

HeraHaven AI interface
HeraHaven AI interface

Character Diversity

FantasyGFHeraHaven AI
4.2/5(Very Good)
Great character diversity with limited search options.
3.4/5(Good)
A good selection of characters, but no options to search and filter through them.

FantasyGF

The app gives you 80 characters to choose from - split evenly between realistic and anime-styled companions. The diversity is basic. You get three ethnicities and characters aged 18-30.

FantasyGF character selection

FantasyGF character selection

The platform keeps it simple with just one filter: toggle between realistic or anime characters.

FantasyGF anime selection

FantasyGF anime selection

Want more AI girls? Here's a trick: Follow active creators on the platform. Their public character collections unlock dozens of additional companions you won't find in the main roster.

FantasyGF creator page

FantasyGF creator page

HeraHaven AI

You get three ethnic backgrounds to choose from, characters aged 20-50, and also some anime characters. That's it. No personality filters. No search function. Just straight-up browsing through each character one by one.

HeraHaven keeps things simple, but in this case, maybe too simple. While other apps let you filter by personality traits or use search features, here you'll need to manually check each character.

Herahaven characters

Herahaven characters

Is this a deal-breaker? That depends on what you're after. If you prefer a curated selection over endless options, you might actually enjoy the straightforward approach. If not, I've reviewed several alternatives with more robust character customization.

Customization

FantasyGFHeraHaven AI
4.2/5(Very Good)
Impressive customization experience with a wide range of options.
3.7/5(Good)
More detailed physical customizations would improve the experience.

FantasyGF

FantasyGF lets you customize everything from looks to personality.

Create your own FantasyGF girlfriend

Create your own FantasyGF girlfriend

The appearance editor is straightforward:

  • Choose between anime or realistic style
  • Pick ethnicity
  • Age (18-60)
  • Adjust physical features
FantasyGF custom appearance

FantasyGF custom appearance

You can modify eye color, hairstyle, body type, and proportions. Nothing groundbreaking, but it works well and offers enough options to create a distinct character.

FantasyGF body customization

FantasyGF body customization

Personality settings come in two flavors: 12 preset personalities for quick setup, or custom creation for more control.

FantasyGF custom personality

FantasyGF custom personality

You'll also define your relationship status, her occupation, and hobbies. The preset options are particularly useful if you're new to AI companions and aren't sure where to start.

Setting relationship in FantasyGF

Setting relationship in FantasyGF

While the customization system isn't revolutionary, it's practical and user-friendly. Some options feel limited, but there's enough depth to create a companion that matches your preferences.

HeraHaven AI

Physical customization covers the basics but has some limitations. You can pick from 6 ethnicities and set an age range between 20 and 50 years, though specific ages aren't selectable.

The system lets you adjust standard features like eyes, hair, body type, and choose between realistic or anime styles. Nothing groundbreaking here, but it gets the job done.

Herahaven character traits

Herahaven character traits

The real flexibility comes in personality design. While HeraHaven offers preset traits to start with, you're not locked into them. During my testing, I could type in any personality trait I wanted - making my AI companion as outgoing or reserved as I preferred.

The same goes for their background story. Whether you want a tech-savvy urbanite or a small-town bookworm, the choice is yours.

Chat Experience

FantasyGFHeraHaven AI
4.2/5(Very Good)
Engaging and emotionally deep interactions, but loses authenticity due to overly long, repetitive responses.
4.2/5(Very Good)
Occasional memory lapses and conversational inconsistencies.

FantasyGF

During chatting, my AI girl maintained her innocent character consistently, even when conversations turned romantic. Instead of explicit responses, she'd suggest things like "Let's take it slow with a massage tonight."

My AI girl handling my concerns

My AI girl handling my concerns

The chat feels personal at first. Your AI girlfriend remembers your conversations, asks about your day, and shows genuine interest in your life. She handles emotional topics well and responds to relationship concerns while keeping her distinct personality traits intact.

My AI girl being too chatty

My AI girl being too chatty

But here's the reality check: the longer you chat, the more artificial it feels. The AI's responses become predictably nice, even when faced with rudeness, and often too long-winded.

Also, my chat history got cut off after extended conversations, and I couldn't access earlier messages (still can't).

HeraHaven AI

During my tests, my shy AI girlfriend consistently matched her personality traits - blushing at compliments but warming up naturally over time.

When asked about ideal dates, she first enthusiastically suggested roller coasters and cotton candy, then thoughtfully added "Well, if we're talking romantic..." before describing a wine and cheese picnic.

This kind of authentic character development shows HeraHaven can maintain personality while navigating romantic conversations.

Herahaven chat

Herahaven chat

But let's be honest - it's not perfect. The AI sometimes forgets important details (like where it works) mid-conversation. Messages can run too long, and you'll occasionally get random images or off-topic responses.

HeraHaven off topic response

HeraHaven off topic response

Bottom line: If you're seeking warm, personality-driven conversations and can handle some technical quirks, HeraHaven delivers. Just don't expect deep emotional complexity or perfect memory retention.

NSFW Chat Experience

FantasyGFHeraHaven AI
3.7/5(Good)
Playful and flirtatious interactions, but they feel somewhat artificial and inconsistent.
4.1/5(Very Good)
Engaging NSFW chat experience with occasional memory and contextual inconsistencies.

FantasyGF

The AI girls start strong - they flirt, they play, they each have their own personality. My AI girlfriend played her "innocent" role well at first. When I suggested some spicy chat, she didn't jump right in. She took her time, stayed true to her character. Nice touch.

My aI girl being too complaint

My aI girl being too complaint

But here's the catch: push the NSFW talk too far, and the whole thing falls apart. That shy, innocent personality? Gone.

Suddenly you're talking to a completely different character. And the longer you chat, the less natural it feels. The AI gets too eager to please, too chatty, too... artificial.

HeraHaven AI

Each AI character handles adult content differently. The nymph character openly discusses sexual preferences and fantasies, while others maintain more reserved personalities.

During my tests, the characters stayed true to their established traits, making conversations feel natural rather than scripted.

But it's not perfect. Memory issues pop up during longer chats, and characters sometimes make odd, unrelated comments. Still, when it comes to flirting and role-play, the AI holds its ground - even when I tried to break character on purpose to test its limits.

Image Generation

FantasyGFHeraHaven AI
4.2/5(Very Good)
High-quality, consistent, and realistic images with minor technical imperfections
3.2/5(Good)
HeraHaven's image generation delivers high-quality visuals with technical inconsistencies.

FantasyGF

The images are high-quality and consistent. My girl looked the same across different pictures, and the overall visual quality matches what you'd expect from premium AI generators.

When I asked for specific poses or expressions, the AI delivered clear, detailed results.

  • Main pose
  • Wearing a bra
  • In a cafe
  • Full body shot, standing, leaning in

But be aware! The platform defaults to NSFW content, even with basic requests like "standing pose" or "friendly smile." There are also occasional visual glitches, as you can see on the pictures (visible bra under breasts).

HeraHaven AI

While the images look stunning at first glance, you'll notice something's off about the eyes.

HeraHaven eyes glitch

HeraHaven eyes glitch

However, more concerning is how your AI girlfriend looks different in each new photo.

  • full body shot
  • close-up portrait shot
  • full body shot
  • wearing professional clothes

The system isn't perfect. During my tests, it crashed for several hours. And when it works, the generated images don't match the personality you've built through chat.

Btw, there's NSFW image generation available, but I'd suggest testing the basic features first to see if they meet your expectations.

Video Generation

FantasyGFHeraHaven AI
4.2/5(Very Good)
Impressive video quality, but it costs a lot of tokens.
1/5(Poor)
Completely lacks video generation.

FantasyGF

You can also create videos of your AI girl, and they look good. They are smooth, realistic, and your AI girlfriend looks exactly like she does in her photos.

But while these videos look great, they're silent. Your AI girl won't speak or make any sounds. It's purely visual interaction.

Now, the elephant in the room - cost. One video nearly wiped out my entire monthly token allowance. Yes, you read that right. So while the technology is impressive, you'll need to decide if spending a large chunk of your tokens on a single video is worth it.

HeraHaven AI

If you're looking for video interactions with your AI girlfriend, you'll need to explore other options.

Voice Generation

FantasyGFHeraHaven AI
3.2/5(Good)
The voices lack natural flow, emotions, and tonality.
3.2/5(Good)
The voice lacks authenticity, sounds robotic, and fails to capture the nuanced personality and cultural essence of the character.

FantasyGF

The voice quality is decent, but you'll notice a robotic undertone. With only 6 voices to choose from, your options are limited.

Greeting
0:00-0:00

I tried setting up an Asian character, but couldn't find a voice that matched the personality - none of the options had the right accent or tone.

Emotional Talk
0:00-0:00

While you'll hear slight variations in expression between different voices, they're not distinct enough to create unique characters. The bottom line? It works, but don't expect anything groundbreaking.

HeraHaven AI

The voice quality is average - clear enough to understand but noticeably artificial. I set up a Latina character profile, but the voice remained generic, missing any trace of cultural accent or personality.

Casual Talk
0:00-0:00

The biggest letdown? Zero emotional range. Happy moments, sad moments, flirty banter - everything comes out in the same flat tone. It's like talking to someone who's reading from a script without any feeling.

Angry Talk
0:00-0:00

If you're okay with basic voice interaction and aren't picky about emotional expression or accent authenticity, it might suit your needs. But if you're seeking a more realistic voice experience, keep looking.

Privacy

FantasyGFHeraHaven AI
3.2/5(Good)
Unclear chat encryption and non-transparent data sharing practices.
4.2/5(Very Good)
Transparent data collection and discrete billing, but lacks explicit confirmation of end-to-end encryption in their policy.

FantasyGF

The app stores all your chat messages and shares them with third parties - they're transparent about this in their policy. Chat encryption? They don't mention it. This means your conversations might not be as private as you'd like.

FantasyGF bank statement

FantasyGF bank statement

Your bank statement will show "Aichatee" - a discrete touch that keeps your AI relationship private from prying eyes. But that's where the privacy features end.

HeraHaven AI

They store your chat messages and user data, and while they claim to use end-to-end encryption, this isn't mentioned in their privacy policy.

HeraHaven bank statement

HeraHaven bank statemet

What I like is the discrete billing. When you check your bank statement, you'll see "herahelp.com" - nothing less, nothing more.